August 31, 2026 · By Steve Presley
Next Sunday at ODCC - The Aftermath

Three Things Nobody Disputes
The Case for Christ — Sermon 14: The Aftermath | Open Door Christian Church
Nobody reading this saw Jesus walk out of the tomb.
Neither did I. Neither did your parents, or their parents, or anyone you have ever met. So when a skeptic says, "You weren't there," he is right. We weren't.
But suppose you run into Publix on a July afternoon with the parking lot bone dry, and twenty minutes later you come out to water standing in the low spots and steam coming up off the asphalt. You didn't see a drop of rain fall. Nobody came and got you to watch. You have no eyewitness at all — and you know exactly what happened.
That is circumstantial evidence. It is not a weaker kind of proof. It is a different kind. Direct evidence is somebody standing up and saying, "I saw it." Circumstantial evidence is a set of facts nobody argues about, and the honest question of what could possibly account for them. Juries are told plainly that it is not inferior to eyewitness testimony, and cases are won on it every week.
For thirteen Sundays we have been calling direct witnesses. This Sunday we do something different. We stop asking who saw Jesus alive and start asking what happened to the people who did.
Because if a man really did come out of a grave in Jerusalem, that is not the sort of event that leaves the world exactly as it found it. It would leave marks. This Sunday we go looking for them.
Lee Strobel's final interview was with Dr. J.P. Moreland, Distinguished Professor of Philosophy at Talbot School of Theology, and he asked for facts nobody disputes. We are going to take three of them.
The men who would not take it back. On Friday they scattered. On Saturday they hid. On Sunday night the doors were locked. Within weeks those same men were standing in front of the council that had condemned Jesus, telling them to their faces that they had killed the wrong man. They were flogged for it and ordered to stop — and the next verse says they went back the following morning. Every one of them had a way out, and it was one sentence long.
The two who changed sides. The early church did not only persuade people sitting on the fence. It picked up two men who were on the other side: a man who hunted Christians for a living, and a brother who had not believed a word of it while Jesus was alive. Both paid dearly for switching. One of them we can confirm from a historian who was not a Christian and had no reason to make Christians look good.
The things that should not have changed. The first believers were devout Jews with fourteen centuries of practice behind them — practice their people had died rather than surrender. Within a few years they had changed how they dealt with sin, what day they gathered, and what they were willing to say about God himself. Then they started two rituals that are stranger than most of us notice: a meal commemorating an execution, and a washing that acts out a burial.
Take any one of those alone and there is something a skeptic can offer. Stack all three in the same direction and the explanations stop adding up.
Join us this Sunday at Open Door Christian Church as we look at the aftermath.